Pisca Andina.

Name: Pisca Andina (Mérida Potato, Milk and Egg Breakfast Soup)
Prep time: 15 min
Cook time: 25 min
Total time: 40 min
Yield: 4 servings
Cuisine: Venezuela
Ingredients: 700 g floury potatoes, peeled and cut into 1.5 cm cubes; 1.2 l water or light chicken stock; 5 scallions, white and green, thinly sliced; 3 cloves garlic, finely chopped; 1 cup cilantro, stems finely chopped and leaves kept separate; 1 tbsp butter; 1½ tsp fine salt; to taste freshly ground black pepper; 500 ml whole milk; 4 eggs; 150 g fresh white cheese, in 1 cm cubes

Mérida Potato, Milk and Egg Breakfast Soup

Pisca andina · say it: PEES-kah ahn-DEE-nah

Pisca andina is a thin, milky potato soup eaten at breakfast in the Venezuelan Andes, and it is designed for cold mornings above two thousand metres. Potatoes are cut small and boiled with garlic, scallion and a great deal of cilantro until they start to break at the edges and cloud the broth, then whole milk goes in, an egg is slipped into each bowl to poach, and cubes of fresh white cheese are added last so they soften without dissolving. The taste is gentle and green — sweet milk, potato starch, and the strong herbal note of cilantro stems, with no chile and almost no fat. Everything happens in one pot in under half an hour, and it is eaten with a wheat arepa for pushing the last of it around the bowl.

Jump to the recipe

Read the story

Mérida Potato, Milk and Egg Breakfast Soup

Gate: VenezuelaMérida and the Venezuelan Andes
Prep: 15 min
Cook: 25 min
Total time: 40 min
Serves: 4
Status: Easy
Nutrition / serving · estimated: Calories 340 kcal; Protein 18 g; Carbs 34 g; Fat 15 g; Fiber 4 g; Sugar 8 g; Sodium 830 mg

Why this recipe works.

The potatoes are cut to a size that breaks down on schedule, so the broth thickens itself without any flour or cream.
The milk goes in off a rolling boil, which is the single thing that stops a milk soup from curdling.
Gives both ways of handling the egg — poached whole or stirred into threads — because Andean households do both.
Cilantro stems and leaves are used at different moments, so the herb flavour is deep rather than just a green garnish.

Tips from our kitchen.

Use a floury or all-purpose potato rather than a waxy one. You want the edges to fray and cloud the broth; waxy potatoes stay in stubborn cubes and the soup never thickens.
Chop the cilantro stems fine and add them with the potatoes, keeping the leaves for the end. The stems carry most of the flavour and need cooking; the leaves only need warming.
Never let the pot boil once the milk is in. Take it down to the barest tremble, or the milk will separate into grains against the acidity of the herbs.
Salt the broth before the milk goes in, and then taste again after. Milk mutes salt noticeably and a bland pisca is a sad thing.
Add the cheese in the bowl, not the pot, so each portion gets cubes that are still recognisable rather than melted threads lost in the broth.
If the soup ends up thinner than you want, crush five or six potato cubes against the side of the pot with a spoon and stir — that is the traditional fix.

Substitutions.

Cebollín (Andean scallion) → Regular scallions, or the green tops of a leek: Use the whole thing, white and green. The green part is not garnish here — it contributes most of the soup's aroma.
Queso blanco fresco → Queso fresco, a mild feta rinsed of brine, or fresh mozzarella cut small: The cheese should soften and go slightly stringy without melting away. Anything aged or hard stays rubbery in a thin broth.
Whole milk → Half milk and half single cream for a richer bowl, or unsweetened oat milk: Oat milk holds up to heat better than nut milks and keeps the soup vegan if you also drop the egg and cheese, though it becomes a different dish.

Variations.

Pisca con papas criollas: Made with small yellow Andean potatoes left whole, which hold their shape and turn the broth a deeper gold. Common where they are grown rather than bought.
Pisca de arroz: A handful of rice cooked alongside the potato, producing a thicker, more filling bowl. Usually made when the soup has to stretch further.
Pisca with beaten egg: Instead of poaching eggs whole, the eggs are beaten and trickled into the simmering broth in a thin stream so they set into fine threads through the soup.

Storage & reheating.

Pisca is best eaten straight from the pot and does not keep especially well, because the potatoes go grainy and the milk is easy to break on reheating. If you have leftovers, refrigerate them for up to 2 days without the egg or cheese and reheat very gently over low heat, stirring, adding a splash of milk to loosen. Do not freeze it: potato and milk both suffer badly, and the soup thaws into something watery with mealy lumps. Better to make the potato base ahead, keep it without milk, and add milk, egg and cheese when you reheat.

Serve with

A wheat arepa or a slice of sturdy bread, and a cup of guayoyo — the long, weak black coffee drunk all morning in the Andes.

The story behind Pisca Andina.

Venezuela is usually pictured as a Caribbean country, and most of its cooking supports that: corn, plantain, coconut, fish. The Andean states — Mérida, Táchira and Trujillo — belong to a different climate and cook accordingly. Up there the staples are potatoes, wheat, milk, trout and cured cheese, mornings are genuinely cold, and the breakfast that answers those conditions is a hot soup rather than a griddled corn cake. Pisca is a páramo dish in the plainest sense: it uses what a highland smallholding has on hand and it warms you from the inside before work.

The name is usually explained as coming from pizca, a pinch, on the grounds that the soup is built from small amounts of several things rather than one substantial ingredient. That reading is repeated widely but is not settled, and other explanations circulate locally; there is no need to pick a winner to cook it. What is agreed is the shape of the thing. Broth, potato, cebollín — the thin Andean scallion — garlic, cilantro, milk, egg, cheese. Some households add a spoon of butter at the end, some use a light chicken broth instead of water, and some crush a few of the potatoes against the side of the pot to thicken the soup. Those are the only real variables.

In Mérida it is served in the morning and, in the cheaper posadas and roadside places along the mountain roads, more or less all day. It arrives with a wheat arepa — in the Andes the arepa is often made with wheat flour rather than corn, thin and slightly flaky, which is another thing that separates this region from the rest of the country. The soup travels badly and is rarely found in restaurants on the coast, so most Venezuelans associate it specifically with going up into the mountains.

Questions, answered.

Why did my milk curdle in the soup?

The pot boiled after the milk went in. Milk proteins separate under high heat, and the acidity from the herbs and the starch in the broth makes it happen faster. Add the milk once the potatoes are cooked, drop the heat immediately, and keep the surface barely trembling. Milk straight from the fridge dumped into a hard-boiling pot is the most common way this goes wrong.

Can I make pisca andina without eggs?

Yes. The soup works perfectly well as potato, herbs, milk and cheese, and plenty of people leave the egg out. If you want the body the egg gives, crush a few more potato cubes against the side of the pot to thicken the broth, or add an extra handful of cheese so the soup is richer. Nothing about the flavour depends on the egg.

Is pisca andina really eaten for breakfast?

It is, in the Venezuelan Andes. Mérida, Táchira and Trujillo sit high and cold, and a hot milky soup at seven in the morning makes obvious sense there in a way it would not on the Caribbean coast. It is served alongside an arepa and coffee. Elsewhere in Venezuela it is more likely to turn up as a light supper, and it works fine as one.

What kind of potatoes should I use?

Floury or all-purpose varieties such as Maris Piper, russet, King Edward or Yukon Gold. They fray at the edges as they cook and release starch that thickens the broth naturally, which is the texture you are aiming for. Waxy salad potatoes hold their shape too well and leave you with cubes floating in thin milk instead of a soup that has body.

How is this different from other potato soups?

It is thinner, and it is not blended or enriched with cream. Most European potato soups are puréed and finished with butter or cream; pisca leaves the potato in visible pieces, uses plain milk for the liquid, and gets its character from a large quantity of cilantro and scallion plus the egg and fresh cheese added at the end. The result is light and herbal rather than smooth and rich.

All recipes →